There
is a huge issue of child soldiers worldwide. Child soldiers are being used
everywhere. The only place they haven’t been used is Antarctica . The majority of child soldiers are
used in Asia . There are many different ways that
children become child soldiers. Based on how they become child soldiers people
have a question if child soldiers are either victims or perpetrators. Child
soldiers are perpetrators because they were forced to join the army and
manipulated to stay; they had a hard time integrating back into society, and
the view of the people who think that child soldiers are perpetrators are wrong
when they say that child soldiers did everything voluntarily when they actually
didn’t.
The
children were forced to join the army and manipulated to stay. In the article,
“Armed & Underage” the writer talks about former child soldier Ishmael Beah
which said, “When Beah was 13, Sierra Leone was embroiled in a civil war. Rebels
attacked his village, and Beah was separated from his parents. After spending
months wandering through his war-torn country, he was forcibly recruited in Sierra Leone ’s Army. Beah was armed with an AK-47,
drugged, and taught to kill.” Beah was one of the children forced to join the
army. They drugged the children so that they would stay. Another example of how
they were forced to join the army was in “Military History” where the writer
talks about another boy who said, “‘I was attending primary school.’ The young
boy speaks in a monotone, masking his emotions as he recounts events that
irrevocably changed his life. ‘The rebels came and attacked us. They killed my
mother and father in front of my eyes. I was 10 years old. They took me with them.’”
That’s how children were forced to join the army and manipulated to stay.
After being a child soldier, victims
have a hard time integrating back into society. In the article “Military
History” the author elaborates on the aftermath by saying, “For the child
soldiers, the impact of being plunged into war creates problems long after the
end of the actual combat. Many suffer long-term trauma that can disrupt their
development.” Former child soldiers have memories of their experiences of
killing people in the war and had to learn to face these memories and move on
with their life. Many girls had to face memories of being abused. In the
article “Military History” the author describes the hardships of being a girl
child soldier, in which he said, “Girl soldiers are often singled out for
sexual abuse, even by their own commanders, and have a hard time integrating
back into society at war’s end.” They had to get used to being around men in
society while facing the memories of being abused by other men in the war. They
would be scared to interact with men prior to previous experiences and had the
thought of potentially being abused again. After being forcibly recruited to
war, child soldiers had to face the unwanted memories of combat and try to
integrate back into society.
Some believe that child soldiers are
perpetrators but if they think critically, they’ll see that they’re actually
victims. In the article “Armed & Underage” the author describes an army of
child soldiers who aren’t willingly prone to violence in which he says, “It is
less an army than a drugged-out street gang with military-grade weapons and
13-year-old brides. Its ranks are filled with boys brainwashed to burn down
huts and pound newborn babies to death.” People who say child soldiers are perpetrators
would say that the quote shows that the child soldiers committed horrifying
crimes. It actually shows that when the child soldiers were brainwashed they
did whatever the commander told them to do. Later in the article the author
includes a quote from a commander explaining the reason behind targeting
children to be soldiers. The quote said, “‘Child soldiers are ideal,’ a
military commander from Chad told Human Rights Watch. ‘They don’t
complain, they don’t expect to be paid – and if you tell them to kill, they
kill.’” This shows how the commanders took advantage of the children’s’
obedience. People who think that child soldiers are perpetrators think that
child soldiers willingly stayed in the war without escaping to get away from
killing. In the Interview if Ishmael Beah video, Ishmael Beah said, “You’ve
lost yourself. It completely becomes your life. You have to do it to survive.”
The people who think that child soldiers are perpetrators should know that they
are wrong because the child soldiers couldn’t escape. If they did escape the
army would hunt them down and kill them. So, child soldiers are victims because
everything they did was involuntary.
Overall, child soldiers are victims.
Child soldiers were forced to join the army when they were captured or in other
ways. They had a hard time integrating back into society with all the trauma
prior to the war. Lastly, the people who think that child soldiers are
perpetrators are completely wrong when they say that the child soldiers did
everything voluntarily, when they had to do it to survive. What side do you
take, perpetrators or victims?
I think this a a really good response, and I agree that child soldiers are victims, although they may turn in to perptrators (some what). I like how you took evidence from the article making it a lot more persuasive.
ReplyDelete